Something like :
Doctors in order
Top 10 Companions
Top 10 Monsters
Favourite Episode per forum member
Nu-who/Classic Who debate thing?

We can do that!

So favourite Doctors? I can make quite a compelling case for Colin Baker though I believe it probably should be Hartnell or Baker at number 1!

Ahhh Strax is totally awesome love Strax!

I guess on that basis it might be the only thing we can say about him.

I think Tennant has to be high up, at least in the top 5. He's pretty great as the Doctor and I think if we're using that for Hartnell then Tennant is pretty important in how the show has started to grow now.

Still think Pertwee should be pretty high up. Pertwee will be the man we mainly agree with!

1 : Jon Pertwee
2 : Matt Smith
3 : Colin Baker
4 : Harntell I put him here as he must have been pretty good but not really watched much.
5 : Peter Davison -
6 : Troughton I do like him but he had to be put somewhere I wish we could do ties.
7 : Christopher Eccleston mainly due to the gas mask episode and the zombie one with Dickens.
8 : Tom Baker
9 : David Tennant
10 : Mcgann
11 : McCoy

1 : Daleks as they frightened me when I was a child and they still make me a little bit spooked lol
2 : The evil spiders - can't remember what they were really called but they were mean!
4 : The Silence
5 : Daemons
6 : Weeping Angels
7 : Whisper Men
8 : Candyman - evil Bertie Bassett I loved him!!!!!
9 : Soltarans
10 : Sea Devils


10 companions?

1 : Teegan
2 : Jo
3 : River
4 : Sarah Jane
5 : Martha
6 : Leela
7 : Donna
8 : Yates
9 : Brigadere
10 : Rory

1. Pertwee - Agreed that his era is probably the easiest just to watch, his "family" feeling TARDIS crew were a big plus for him as well. Actually don't think he gets the love he deserves.
2. Smith - Seeing we all have to agree on this to be honest Moff's era and Matt's Doctor are our favourite, some of us liked Tennant and Eccleston but Matt is universally liked on here so why not?
3. Troughton - Again we seem to all like him and we all rushed onto iTunes to buy the missing episodes so as a forum we do tend to like him moreso then others.
4. T.Baker - Because he has to be in the top 5, he is the icon and was my favourite growing up.
5. C.Baker - Just because I love him under rated!
6. Hartnell - Like his episodes and think he was a good Doctor and he WAS the first!
7. McGann - Well today proved that he was under rated and really good.
8. Eccleston - Wish we had more of him!
9. Tennant - Bored me.
10. Davison - Bored me.
11. McCoy - I've seen a few of his episodes, probably most of it, but there was something... Flat about it.


Top 10 Villians.

1. The Master - A real threat to the Doctor, just as smart as him and been played by some GREAT actors!
2. Yeti - Why not?
3. Weeping Angels - I still like them.
4. Daleks - As I said bored of them now.
5. The Great Intelligence - I enjoy his stories REG was great as him!
6. The Silence - Really enjoyed them, wish they'd come back!
7. Sontarans - .
8. Cyberman - Could be great like in classic series (which is why they are here) but they are getting better.
9. Sif - Just because I can (was he called Sif? The little worm thing .)
10. The Kandyman - I liked him .

Top 10 Companions.

1. The Brig - Because he is and always will be a companion!
2. Jamie - He was in a way a match for Troughton, always kept him honest and something the show should do again. Nice that the Doctor really did just have a friend.
3. Rory *Pond* Williams - Best "Nu-Who" companion so far .
4. River - Yes I love River to DEATH!
5. Jo - Wonderful companion and was so happy she got a happy ending and left the Doctor for her own reasons!
6. Leela - Really enjoyed her learning along the way, such a different character and brilliant!
7. Sarah Jane - She is the iconic companion, and I do love her, but I do think being the iconic companion people think of her in a higher light then they need to at times.
8. K-9 - .
9. Amy Pond - Yep I love her too.
10. Ian - I always loved seeing him contradict the Doctor! Always fun.

I don't mind having a guest one as well, would be quite interesting.

Doctors

1. Hartnell because he is the first and I think we should recognize that. None of this "what if" bullshit, he is the first Doctor and without him who DOES know what would have happened?
2. Eccleston because he brought the show back to a new audience.
3. T.Baker because he is the iconic Doctor, the one everyone can remember. Personally feel the same as Anna, he was my favorite and he was my first but since I grew up a little I get bored with his era.
4. Pertwee because his era is the most watchable on a board day and I do like the UNIT family.
5. Davison because his TARDIS team were pretty great and personally I felt like he had some great episodes.
6. McGann because he's the underrated and forgotten one most of the time and I think we should reflex the popularity he obviously has in the poll, after all this minisode feels like it's killed some fans with wonder.
7. C.Baker because he did get a hard wrap and was such a wonderfully different Doctor.
8. Tennant because like him or not he is popular and we probably only still have the show now because of his popularity.
9. Smith because even though we all like him he isn't really that well thought of.
10. Troughton because I can't really comment on his series.
11. McCoy because I disliked his era really. Nothing against McCoy who was actually a great Doctor, it was never the Doctor I disliked.

Top 10 Villians

1. The Master, it has to be him.
2. The Daleks, iconic and the only reason the show was so popular.
3. Autons, great idea and always loved their stories.
4. The Ice Warriors, even if they aren't always the bad guy. Love the Ice Warriors.
5. Dream Lord because I loved the concept of him...
6. Valeyard likewise.
7. Weeping Angels, though only just because they are being diluted with every new story.
8. Family Slitheen because underneath the farting I thought they were quite good. No kidding.
9. The Mara, good stories.
10. GI because he was a great foe last series and the Web of Fear was wonderful.

Top 10 companions

1. Sarah Jane, the iconic companion.
2. Brig, another icon.
3. Ian & Barbara as they should be together not separate.
4. Leela, loved the whole back story and her "learning" to be civilized etc. Great actress too.
5. Jamie, what I've seen of him he's pretty good.
6. Amy & Rory, I liked the bold story Moffat tried to tell with them, I feel he might have known he had limited time though and it felt squashed into one series.
7. Harry, I've always liked him.
8. Jo, its hard not to like her.
9. Susan, didn't like her as much as Ian and Barbara but quite an important character.
10. Rose because whether I like her or not she's important.

I think the guest thing should probably be top 5 in stead of 10. It doesn't seem quite as important. My top 5 is

1. Wilf. Who can't love him? Only good part of Tennants era.
2. Prof Clifford Jones, really enjoyed the episode and happy Jo found someone worthy of her.
3. Strax. Not keen on Jenny or Vastra all the time but I love Strax.
...

I'll get back to you on two others.

I'd be happy with that, and at the moment it looks like a fair summary of our feelings.

Pete will be online in about 30 minutes and Amanda is still hanging around online so we should have their two's opinion in good time. What will we do about the others?

Sorry  messed up your calculations already! That will be fair for that one yes I think the others we'll have to talk it through and quick about it! If Pete is on in awhile like Rick said though it shouldn't matter too much as we'll all be done as long as we all come on again tomorrow and Saturday!