Like you I think this worked best for me on a second viewing, the first time you were trying to catch hold of where the story was going, not only that but personally I hadn't read anything about it, I didn't need to I love these two so was undoubtely going to love the series, so I was always waiting to see another room or them just getting out of the closet. I guessed about 20 different endings but in the last five minutes when it all started to piece together my mouth was wide open.

I think that is something you don't really get on TV very well these days, I've not really watched anything that has left me gobsmacked by the end.

Second viewing you know which pieces to piece together, but also because you are used to the set and you are not trying to figure out what is going on you get the subtle little jokes as well.

But it was actually quite a sad little piece!

I have to say I called the ending from the start, the moment I saw the girlfriend/wife come downstairs I knew the boyfriend/husband was going to kill her. Unlike the first one I don't think the ending was quite as jaw dropping, as I said I knew that the women was going to die, didn't think the man or the two robbers would, but that was just because of the added cleaner at the end.

It was still awesome though. It showed that silent episodes can work, the comedy was a little more blunt but it was choreographed so beautifully with all the main players and worked so well that it was like two mini-stories being told.

Better then the first and gave you a great sense of expectation for the series because Sardines was so good to have something blow it out of the water (and importantly NOT TAKING AWAY FROM THE AMAZINGNESS OF IT) you kind of hope every episode is like that.

I should have ******* guessed the ending! Can't believe I didn't! With the name Tom and Gerri and the only message you ever got to see left for him was from Stevie and the fact she never came back to the flat and there was long gazes at her photos I should have ******* guessed she was the ghost! Instead I really ******* believed it was Migg! And to be honest it is rare now that a double switch works and it worked perfectly!

This really was more drama then comedy and it was so dark. It was great. Not sure I was meant to be laughing that Gerri was nearly a head taller then Tom but I did find that funny (hard to find women as small as Reece I guess ) but that aside it was just great.

I'll have to watch it another five times before I tell you what I think really in any depth because my mind was just blown!

Jan and Graham ask WishmakerUK to brighten up their daughter's birthday.

I wanted something a little more with the little girl. I know the point is that the parents were selfish but it just never really worked for me. Steve Pemberton didn't work against any of the other characters, they were all too similar. Tasmin Greig was great but again they were all acting similar and it just left the episode feeling over blown with similar characters. That and the fact there wasn't a great last minute twist and Reece wasn't in the episode I just felt it was a bit of a let down.

By now I should really get that the obvious answer isn't going to be THE answer but gods dammit I still fell for it this week! Really thought that it was Laura that did it, didn't even think twice about Kirstie! Just thought she was a random extra, though I'm now wondering why I thought she'd be a random extra haha! Wonderful episode, shows how good they are when they play off each other. I do feel that Reece is the slightly better one at portraying a lot of different characters, Steve tends to remind me of one of two characters. This one or the one from last week, there never seems to be a in between. That sounds really mean though and I love Steve so I'm going to shut up.

OK I lie, he also does David. Ahhh David .

And Tubbs....

See I'm already proving myself to be a idiot!

Loved the twist and the use of Macbeth imagery (bloody dagger and all that) was really a great show.

To be honest I'll agree that the effects looked naff but the fact they used them I can see why and it was good imagery to have. The problem being their budget was probably tiny and nowhere near enough to pull off that kind of stunt.

I will disagree, respectively, I think the actress that played Laura did it wonderfully. I really did believe that she could have done anything though I would have liked to have seen a little more of why Shearsmiths character would have decided against caring about her within seconds.