OK so I'm nearly finished with Coven and this is how I feel so far about the three seasons.
Coven by far has the best story. It is a simple one, very linear and the threads away from the main story aren't over the top or take away from the main story itself. Saying that I've found it boring, the cast is bland even if it is the same cast as most other series, Jennifer Lange and Kathy Bates are all that makes the series watchable. The four teenage witches started off well enough but now by episode 9 are all rather bland, you have two airheaded blonde girls who always look good even though they **** shit up and the other two, Queenie and Nan,, never get enough credit or screen time.
Its like Vampire Diaries with witches.
The Asylum was the most beautiful. I loved the visuals of being in a insane Asylum back in the day. The cast was great, I loved having Joseph Fiennes in the episodes because he was one of my first ever celeb crushes
. I liked the bleak, dark and dirty feel.
The main story annoyed me, I hated Sarah Pulson's character Lana, she got herself into the mess she was in, she always felt sorry for herself, she was a compulsive liar, she was cold and calculating and then when she got out she didn't do what she promised until there was something in it for her. The final episode saw a old her telling the world what a bitch she was but she never really changed and she grated on me.
The second main story on the side of the aliens with Evan Peters character was silly and didn't really belong in it. It took away from what could have been quite a great story without it. Plus I don't get the whole being SOOO in love with his dead wife that he fucks some random women he meets in the Asylum, and when she has his baby he's so happy about it all that he forgets his dead wife and then when his dead wife is still alive (baring in mind that crazy psycho baby mumma told him she was dead) he goes into a polygamuous relationship. Of course the two women were abducted by aliens and implanted with two perfect babies made from the DNA of Peters character, and of course when he is close to death the aliens abduct him. We get no real reason why they are interested in him other then to be told he's really emphetic... Which we didn't actually see at all during the whole of the bloody series!
Zachary Quinto's character was good as was James Cromwells, Jessica Lange and Joseph Fiennes. But they interchanged into a few really different storylines, any one which could have been brilliant on its own but was all crammed into the one series which ended up making it all feel a bit flat.
Murder House.... Well I thought the story was stupid, I thought the ending was unfulfilling and I thought that the character development, histories and stories were all stupid.
But there was something charming about it.
The cast were great. Jessica Lange once more (or should I say for the first time since I've reviewed them backwards) was amazing, Evan Peters really stood out, Dylan McDermott was amazing though I thought his story was insanely stupid, Connie Britton was perfect for her role, Francis Conroy was another stand out that I'd never heard of, Lily Rabe is actually one of my favourite characters in EVERY season so far and to see Matt Ross once more in anything that kind of creeps me out is great as he (along with Julian Sands) was my favourite character in Stephen Kings Rose Red.
It wasn't as good story wise or visually as the other two but I think its the best one. The characters are probably the best, you invested in every single one, none of them annoyed me but the one thing I hated was we didn't really get to see a end for all the ghosts. I would have loved to see like a spirit council or something seeing they had the modern family and the modern psycho all living under the roof now.
Saying all of the above I think this series is AWESOME. The only series that has bored me a bit is the Coven which I have to admit I've blacked out on more then one occasion because I don't like the teen angst which even Sarah Pulson's character is suffering from.
I can't wait to get this done with and get to Freak Show though
.