For me both would do a good job. You can't make everyone happy at once, but both would make their own fans happy and that is what is important!

Whether you like RTD or Moff you should be happy and proud of whatever the 50th story is! Of course if either would write a piece of NuWho twaddle I wouldn't be happy but why the heck would two giant fans of the show not celebrate? They've been given a anniversary special to celebrate so why use it to peddle their wares?

I keep saying they because there is no way of making it sound like a hypothetical world as well as this real world we are in.

My idea when I realized the 50th was coming up was two specials. One by RTD one by Moffat, or else them working together. If anything there needs to be a tiny bit before this episode with both RTD and Moff. If I had the know how to find a way I'd send both my gratitude as we wouldn't have Who if we didn't have them!

I'm sorry I'll just go and cry in my corner

Personal preference is the important part. If you don't like RTD then you'd probably prefer Moff. If you don't like Moff you'd probably like RTD. If you like neither then your buggered. You never know they could both of surprised their naysayers but we'll never know for RTD. But it'll be successful just because someone somewhere will like it.

I'm not a nice person. Moff will do it better then RTD would for me. I can't stand a lot of RTDs stories, nothing about his era which had some really good episodes, but I think I liked one RTD story (Midnight) so I wouldn't want him to do the anniversary.

The only way Moff can annoy me is if he ONLY brings back Tennant or some other shit from RTDs era but doesn't have anything about anything other then RTD stuff. I don't even care if he just does his own thing with River Song it would be preferable to that idiot John Barrowman ever returning

Only Pete could ever start a post with "I'm not a nice person" and be lying.

We all know he is a RTD fanboy.